Everything seemed to be going the 1964 Phillies’ way. Up by 6 1/2 games with just 12 left to play in the season, they appeared to have clinched their first pennant in 14 years. Outfielder Johnny Callison narrowly missed being the National League MVP. Third baseman Richie Allen was Rookie of the Year.

But they didn’t make it to the postseason — they lost 10 straight and finished a game behind the St. Louis Cardinals, who ended up winning the World Series vs. the Yankees. It was the greatest collapse in baseball history. Here is a pristine sheet of World Series tickets that the Phillies had printed up, everyone thinking they were a lock for the National League Pennant. But the baseball Gods had something else planned for the Phillies. It took them another 16 years to get to the Series after their September swoon of '64.